Birdies The Starling Vegan Velvet Slip On Loafers Flats Blue Gray Women's Size 7. Flaw: Last two pictures show some marks. Shoes are in good preowned condition due to some marks/flaws in the velvet. Per Birdies website, "A classic smoking slipper crafted of premium velvet, this shoe is soft to the touch and has a subtle sheen. We covered our footbeds with a satin lining for added luxury and comfort. - Classic smoking slipper flat with 8 mm heel - Our Starling black velvet flats are rated five-star fabulous by 15,000+ women - Crafted of luxurious vegan velvet - No-slip rubber sole for indoor + outdoor wear - 7 layers of cloud-like comfort in every footbed - Due to the nature of velvet, color variances may appear in this textured fabric depending on the angle captured and source of light" Brand New - never been worn or washed, perfect condition Excellent - preowned, perfect condition Very Good - preowned, some signs or wear and/or possible flaws Good - preowned, definite signs of wear and/or possible flaws Fair - preowned, significant wear and flaws